Difference Between Allstate and Auto Owners (With Table)

Allstate, formed in 1931, is America’s biggest publicly traded private lines insurer. General Robert E. Wood, a previous Sears, Roebuck & Co-President and Board Chairman, created it. In a small office in the Commercial Block Building in Mount Pleasant, Michigan, Vern V. Moulton and four of his friends established Auto-Owners Insurance Company.

Allstate vs Auto-Owners

The main difference between Allstate and Auto-Owners is that Allstate scored an A- from the Better Business Bureau (BBB), while Auto-Owners received an A+. Auto-owners and Allstate are well-known for their vehicle insurance coverage, but you can also receive a home, renters, commercial, pet, and health insurance. They are among the top insurance providers, yet each has advantages and disadvantages.

General Robert E. Wood, who first sold insurance via mail, transformed his ideas into an innovative commercial move. The name Allstate was inspired by a tire offered in a Sears catalog, and the initial sales site was in a Sears shop in Chicago. The first claim was made to a guy who arrived at the office clutching a car door handle in his hand following an attempted automobile theft.

Auto-Owners Insurance had only one portfolio of policyholders and $174.25 in total assets in its first year. Auto-Owners expanded beyond Michigan in 1935 and began issuing policies in Indiana. In 1951, the firm relocated into its new four-story headquarters in downtown Lansing, with 400 employees. Auto-Owners Insurance was ranked 375 in 2018.

Comparison Table Between Allstate and Auto-Owners

Parameters of Comparison




Allstate was founded in the year of 1931.

Auto-Owners was founded in the year of 1916.

Market Share

Allstate has a market share of 4.9%.

Auto-Owners has a market share of 0.24%


Allstate received a rating of A- from BBB.

Auto-Owners received a rating of A+ from BBB.

Payment Options

Allstate accepts all kinds of payments starting from online transactions to cheques.

Auto-Owners accepts only one kind of payment and that is automatic online payment.

Complaint Rates

Allstate has an NAIC Complaint Index of 1.03.

Auto-Owners has an NAIC Complaint Index of 0.77.

What is Allstate?

Allstate, established in 1931, is the nation’s biggest publicly traded personal lines insurer. General Robert E. Wood, a former Sears, Roebuck & Co-President and Board Chairman, formed it and first sold insurance over the mail, an innovative commercial strategy. The name Allstate was inspired by a tire offered in a Sears catalog, and the initial sales site was in a Sears shop in Chicago.

The first claim was made to a guy who arrived at the office clutching a car door handle in his hand following an attempted automobile theft. In the 1950s, the firm grew beyond vehicle insurance to provide life, health, and commercial insurance as well. In addition, the corporation began training high school students about driving and marketing on televisions. The organization caters to the special demands of a broad customer and has earned honors for promoting multiculturalism in the workforce and providing possibilities for promotion to women in particular.

Allstate was designated one of the top 50 creative adopters of computer technology by InformationWeek in 2005. In 2005, Fortune magazine named Allstate the second most regarded firm in the Property and Casualty industry. In the 1960s, Allstate became a champion for mandating seat belt use, and in the late 1960s, it began marketing commercial coverage.

What is Auto-Owners?

Auto-Owners Insurance Company covers a far broader range of clients than only car owners. Through independent agents in 26 states, the firm provides over a dozen different forms of insurance. People who require several insurance policies may benefit from the ease and advantages that come with combining them with Auto-Owners, which offers a wide range of coverage alternatives. Auto-Owners provides all of the standard coverages, like liability, various state-required coverage kinds, breakdown cover, and extensive and catastrophe insurance.

In addition, the organization provides a variety of add-on coverages and alternatives. If you have house insurance with Vehicle-Owners in addition to a comprehensive auto policy. If you have to file a claim under both policies for the same occurrence, such as a severe storm or a tree falling on both your house and car, the insurer will decrease your auto cost by the value of your home risk. If your home’s deductible is larger than your vehicle deductible, the firm will waive your car deductible.

The Auto-Owners collision coverage benefit is divided into two components. To begin, if you are in an accident with another firm customer, your accident deductibles will be eliminated. Second, if you are in an accident with an animal, Auto-Owners will pay from either your accident or full insurance, whichever is greater. Animal crashes are rigorously covered under comprehensive coverage by the majority of insurers.

Main Differences Between Allstate and Auto-Owners

  1. Allstate was put in place in 1931 by General Robert E. Wood, whereas Auto-Owners was set up in 1916 by Michigan, Vern V. Moulton, and four of his friends.
  2. Allstate has a 4.9 percent industry share, while Auto-Owners has a 0.24 percent industry share.
  3. Allstate obtained an A- rating from BBB, while Auto-Owners achieved an A+ rating.
  4. Allstate allows various types of payment transactions, from online purchases to checks, whereas Auto-Owners only takes one type of billing: automatic online payment.
  5. The NAIC Complaint Index for Allstate is 1.03, while the NAIC Complaint Index for Auto-Owners is 0.77.


Allstate provides a variety of customizable insurance products. Clients can save money if they insure their house and car with Auto-Owners Insurance because of the shared loss threshold and multi-policy benefits. Allstate Mobile is accessible for both iOS and Android devices. The Auto-Owners Insurance smartphone app is ready for both iOS and Android devices. This insurance advisor provides you accessibility to your policy 24 hours a day, seven days a week. 

Both of them have their pros and cons, but they are among the best insurance companies in the world. Both firms have strong financial positions. Both insurance companies provide their clients with Auto, Home, Life, Business, Renters, Condo, Motorcycle, as well as RV coverage. Allstate also provides Landlord insurance and other services. Auto-Owners provides a range of product lines that Allstate does not, including Boat, Flood, as well as Pet protection. There are various ways to save money with Allstate and Auto-Owners.


  1. https://heinonline.org/hol-cgi-bin/get_pdf.cgi?handle=hein.journals/byulr1998&section=53
  2. https://hcommons.org/deposits/download/hc:38010/CONTENT/king98fulltext.pdf/